So is there any hope for such reform from the Democrats? Word from Washington so far: Fat chance. As reported in the LA Times two weeks ago… the crucial House IP subcommittee will be chaired by Hollywood Howard (Berman) â€” among the most extreme of the IP warriors. It is this committee that largely determines what reform Congress considers. It is the Chairman who picks what voices get heard. And while Berman is a brilliant man â€” whose brilliance could really have been used in the problems facing the mid-east â€” his brilliance has not yet been directed towards working out the problems of IP and the Net with any view beyond the narrowest of special interests.This is like making a Congressman from Detroit head of a Automobile Safety sub-committee, or a Senator from Texas head of a Global Warming sub-committee. Are you kidding, Dems? The choice signals clearly the partyâ€™s view about the issues, and its view of the â€œsolutionâ€: more of the same. This war â€” no more successful than President Bushâ€™s war â€” will continue.
No doubt, there are Net issues beyond copyright â€” surveillance, net neutrality, etc. But I suggest this choice is an important signal about this party (and Iâ€™m afraid, any party). I once asked a senior staffer of a brilliant Senator why the Senator didnâ€™t take a stronger position in favor of Net Neutrality. â€œNo Senator remains a Senator opposing an industry with that much moneyâ€ was his answer.
And so too here. The Dems have looked at the potential â€œreturnâ€ from the activists on the Net. Theyâ€™ve considered the kids being sued by the industry (including the kids running MySpace, and maybe soon, YouTube), and the kids creating amazing new (but presumptively illegal) mashups and remixes, and they have compared that value to the party with the value promised by Hollywood. Result: the 20th Century continues to rule.
Dems to the Net: â€œThanks for the blogs. And please continue to get outraged by MoveOn messages. But donâ€™t think for a second weâ€™re interested in hearing anything beyond the charming wisdom of Jack Valenti. We appreciate your support. We appreciate your money. But come on â€” youâ€™re all criminals. Donâ€™t expect your criminal ways to be taken seriously by an institution as respected as the US Congress.â€
Yeah.Â The Democrats may be on the good side of a lot of issues but so far on technological and creative issues they’re pretty much corporate whores.Â Disappointing.Â There are really no good guys in power on these issues.
As Lessig points out, the irony is that the Democrats have been very well served by the disruptive technologies that they’re lining up to fight.