Gossamer Commons

I’m adding a new webcomic to the small list of comics I read: Gossamer Commons. It’s written by Eric Burns, who writes the blog “Websnark,” which often critiques webcomics. It’s a fairly new project. I heard about it through Websnark. I read a couple of the “intro” comics, and then I read the big “splash page” comics — and I stopped. Man that was one ugly ass little fairy freak. I just couldn’t see reading any further if there was any chance I’d have to look at that big-eyed monstrosity again.

But I had put the strip’s RSS feed in my reader, and so, day by day, I kept seeing notifications of new strips. I ignored them for a while, but then finally I decided to go back and give it another chance.

I’m glad I did. It looks like it’s gonna be a good little story. I think I’d find the Trudy character annoying if I she didn’t totally remind me of someone I actually knew when I lived in a college town like that. It was kind of fun seeing a Brent and Francis (from PVP) cameo. The story setup is complete by now and it looks like it’s going to be a fun ride.

I don’t think I follow any other “story-only” as opposed to “punchline-oriented” webcomics. If this one can hold me it’ll be a first.

Despots and Nannies

“A despot welcomes a riot. Disorder provides an excuse to rescind liberties in order to restore calm. There are only two choices, after all: chaos and control. Even the creators of Get Smart understood that.”

So says Alfie Kohn in an article on nanny reality shows.

And it’s funny, I was just thinking that.

In a series of discussions about whether, at base, civilization depends on violence, somebody suggested that the reason Gandhi’s nonviolence worked was that the gigantic pile of followers could conceivably have turned violent at any moment — that that threat of violence was what was behind it all. Same with MLKJr.

That is completely in disagreement with my understanding of the dynamics of nonviolent power: a violent mob is easy to deal with: you fight them. You destroy them. You use greater force. The fact that they fought you proves that your power is needed to keep order. Rebellion supports authority. It’s all part of the same dynamic.

Nonviolent resistance somehow breaks that cycle, in a way that I don’t totally understand, but in a way that has worked many a time.

In a sense, nonviolent resistance works because it enlists the oppressor in the service of liberation: it tries to deliver both oppressor and oppressed from the yoke of oppression that binds them equally. That was how Arnold Toynbee saw it:

To Toynbee, Gandhi was “as much a benefactor of Britain as of his own country. He made it impossible for us to go on ruling India, but at the same time he made it possible for us to abdicate without rancour and without dishonour.”

Kohn continues to critique the disturbing ideology of the nanny shows, and it’s worth reading, but there’s a lot to be said for the political truth of that little one-liner at the beginning.

Episcopa Vagans

Huh. Just found out that a friend of mine is now a bishop.

For reasons I’m not even going to begin to explain, she sought ordination as a priest and bishop in the Apostolic Succession from nontraditional sources, and the presiding bishop of the Universal Anglican Church saw fit to grant her request. I’m not sure of the precise line of their apostolic succession but it’s ultimately through one of those Episcopi Vagantes type sources where everybody’s obsessively reconsecrating each other so in order for the consecrations to be invalid three dozen different lines of succession would have to all be invalid.

I saw a copy of the rite of consecration they wrote. It was quite beautiful.

I am told that one of the clergy who came to town to do the rite of consecration was wandering around a local Border’s in vestments and was mistaken for a Sith Lord. :)

Oops

Upgraded to WP1.5.1. Forgot to copy over the .htaccess file. Broke the entire site except for the front page. Didn’t notice. It’s fixed now. Thanks to the folks who pointed it out to me.

Ungrateful Wretch!

“Look, kid, you can prattle on with your silly idealistic notions about a world without human sacrifice, but the only reason you haven’t been smited by angry, bloodthirsty gods is the proud men and women who go up on the pyramids and rip the still beating hearts out of helpless victims and offer them up in supplication. And I hope you aren’t cornered by an angry god some day without a human-sacrificing priest to protect you, because all your no-ripped-out-and-bleeding-heart liberal ideals aren’t going to stop that angry god from cursing you with boils and carbuncles, blighting your crops, slaying your children, and making your wife barren.

“So talk all you want, but the only reason you can even say those disrespectful, foolish things, is the hard work of our proud sacrificial priesthood, who have convinced the gods not to make your tongue cleave to the roof of your mouth.”

That’s what you hear (mutatis mutandis) if you question the necessity of war and violence on the Internet.

UPDATE/CLARIFICATION: Clearly this isn’t an argument or anything like that. There are some holes in the analogy, as with any analogy. It’s just meant as a kind of look inside my head, at how it sounds to me when people say certain things. I’ve been in some discussions about violence on various blogs lately and more than once I’ve gotten this kind of talk back at me. The metaphor to human sacrifice hit me this morning so I thought I’d write it up.

So it’s not meant as an argument to show people why they ought to think like me, far from it, it’s meant more as picture to show people how someone could think this way, and how certain kinds of arguments against it (“you’re insulting the very soldiers who fight for your freedom to say these things!”) come across.